In October 2026, BYD found itself facing a trademark infringement action in Indonesia. The plaintiff, PT Raden Reza Adi, holds the registered "Denza" mark in Class 12 (vehicles and parts) and claims that BYD has "no right to use" it, seeking material damages of IDR 9.5 trillion and asking the court to order a halt to the import, sale and promotion of all vehicles bearing the "Denza" mark, together with a recall of products already sold.
This did not come out of nowhere. Looking back along the timeline, BYD had at least two opportunities to avoid this outcome.
The Indonesian company PT Worcas Nusantara Abadi registered the "Denza" mark with Indonesia's Directorate General of Intellectual Property (DJKI) on 3 July 2023, covering Class 12 vehicles and parts, with protection running to 2033. BYD did not file in the same class until 8 August 2024.
In a first-to-file jurisdiction, that thirteen-month interval is decisive. Indonesian trademark law protects whoever files first, not whoever uses first in the market. BYD had already brought the Denza D9 to the Indonesian market by January 2025, but a product arriving first and a registration arriving later cannot change who owns the right in law.
In January 2025, BYD brought a cancellation action, arguing that Denza is a globally well-known mark and that the other party had registered in bad faith. On 28 April 2025, the Commercial Court at the Central Jakarta District Court dismissed all of its claims, holding that the registration complied with the first-to-file principle and that BYD had failed to prove that Denza had become well known within Indonesian territory.
Worse was to follow. In September 2024, the mark had already been assigned to PT Raden Reza Adi, and that assignment had been recorded before BYD filed. BYD named the original registrant as defendant; in a 2026 final ruling the Supreme Court held that this was an "error in persona" — the wrong party had been sued — and dismissed all of BYD's claims. A case fought for more than a year ended on a procedural point, without the core issue ever being reached.
IDR 9.5 trillion is an astronomical figure, but the deadliest item on the plaintiff's list is not the damages — it is the demand to cease use and recall the products. For a premium brand that has only just begun deliveries in Indonesia, an order granting that request would wipe out the channel build-out, brand promotion and consumer recognition accumulated to date.
BYD's response was to change its name. From October 2026, the brand identity in the Indonesian market shifted from "Denza" to "Danza". One letter, and the infringement risk is avoided — at the cost of a break in brand recognition and the expense of rebuilding it.
One might ask: if the squatter never genuinely uses the mark, can it not be cancelled?
Indonesian trademark law does provide for non-use cancellation, but the threshold has been raised. From 30 July 2024, the Constitutional Court's decision No. 144/PUU-XXI/2023 extended the "continuous non-use" period from three years to five, and requires the party seeking cancellation to provide evidence of non-use covering the full five-year period. PT Worcas registered in July 2023; on a five-year count, the earliest point at which non-use cancellation becomes available is July 2028 — assuming the proprietor never genuinely uses the mark in the Indonesian market. For a product already launched in Indonesia, waiting for such an uncertain cancellation window is commercially unrealistic.
Around the same period, another Chinese carmaker found a different route through in Indonesia. XPENG sued an Indonesian individual who had squatted the "XPENG" mark. Having lost at first instance, it appealed to the Supreme Court. In April 2026, the Indonesian Supreme Court ruled in final instance to cancel the squatted marks, recognise "XPENG" as a well-known trademark and confirm that the registrant had obtained the marks in bad faith. The factors the court weighed included XPENG's trademark filings across multiple markets, its brand promotion record, the extent of public recognition and its prior enforcement practice.
XPENG's route shows that, in a first-to-file jurisdiction, a well-known trademark finding is one of the few weapons in after-the-fact relief capable of piercing the registration barrier — but the evidentiary cost is extremely high, and it depends on cross-market reputation evidence accumulated before the squatting occurred. The route works, but it should not be treated as the first line of defence.
A February 2026 alert issued by the China Trademark Association showed that twelve Chinese liquor brands — including Fenggu, Baiyunbian, Shazhou Youhuang, Kuaijishan and Si Te Jiu — had apparently been squatted in Indonesia by the same entity, in a concentrated, batch operation. "BOSS Zhipin" and "Liepin" have also had their marks registered in Indonesia by others. The squatters' logic is the same: exploit the time gap and information gap in Chinese companies' overseas trademark planning, stake a claim in a target market before the brand arrives, and wait to be bought out or to sue for infringement.
The trigger point for trademark registration should be set at the product planning stage, not at the market-entry stage. Once a company begins assessing channels, pricing and competitors in an overseas market, trademark searches and filings should start in parallel. Indonesia's single-country examination is speeding up, but so are the squatters. The individual fee for designating Indonesia under the Madrid Protocol is CHF 125 per class, and a standard single-country application costs about IDR 1.8 million per class. Set against an IDR 9.5 trillion claim or the cost of a forced rebrand, that upfront spend is nowhere near a decision burden.
The lesson of BYD's Denza case is not that "Indonesia is a high-risk market", but that in a jurisdiction where first-to-file decides everything, the filing date is the right itself. You can sell the product first, but you cannot add the trademark later. The day you add it may be the day someone else is already standing at the finish line.


地址:广州市天河区体育东路116号财富广场东塔18楼
电话:020-22263200,020-22263284
传真:020-22263218
E-mail:smr@smr.com.cn

赛立信研究集团 2017 版权所有 Copyright © 2016 smr.com.cn All Rights Reserved. 粤ICP备:11102332号